Washington, DC – The newly introduced Senate funding bill, if passed, will result in more cruelty and chaos at our nation’s border. The bill is poisoned with extreme anti-immigrant policies that would essentially end access to asylum, a legal pathway for people fleeing persecution. An international aid bill is no place for immigration reform. It is unconscionable to use people seeking asylum as political pawns to gain support for the protection of others. 

The #WelcomeWithDignity Campaign for asylum rights strongly condemns the Emergency National Security Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2024, introduced by Senators Lankford (R-OK), Sinema (I-AZ), and Murphy (D-CT). Among its most damaging provisions, the bill would make it harder to determine whether a person can apply for asylum, allow individuals and families seeking safety to be deported without a fair day in court, and under certain scenarios, deny anyone the opportunity to seek asylum. These proposals will undermine due process and violate international law. They will also fail to decrease the number of people arriving at the border. Deterrence tactics will not and have never worked. 

The latest legislation introduced in the Senate fails to provide practical solutions to the humanitarian needs at the U.S. border. We stand firm that addressing global displacement needs, including at the U.S. border, require thoughtful and humane solutions. These solutions include investing in resources to increase processing capacity at the border, increasing funding to communities and organizations that welcome arriving people, creating additional legal pathways for people to seek safety, and addressing the backlog in asylum and work permit applications.

The #WelcomeWithDignity Campaign strongly urges the Senate to reject this bill. We are grateful to the members of Congress who have expressed grave concerns about the inclusion of provisions that would harm the asylum system in a spending bill, including the Congressional Progressive Caucus, Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus and the Congressional Hispanic Caucus. 

“Over the years, the U.S. has ramped up its cruelty in an attempt to curtail the number of people arriving at its border. Adults and children have been put in cages, families have been separated, the border has been closed and, still, people continue to seek safety. People flee their home countries out of necessity. This bill will not stop people from coming; it will only lead to more cruelty and chaos at the border,” said Melina Roche, #WelcomeWithDignity Campaign Manager. “As a nation, we must remember and embrace our shared humanity and reject extreme anti-immigrant sentiments that punish people for seeking safety. We must save asylum.”

“The rights of people seeking asylum must be protected, not traded away like political bargaining chips,” said Blaine Bookey, Legal Director of the Center for Gender & Refugee Studies (CGRS). “While the White House has touted this deal as a ‘tough’ move to address challenges at our southern border, anyone who has been paying attention to asylum policy in recent years sees it for what it is: a shameful attempt at political posturing that treats refugees’ lives as expendable. The government has tried these ‘tough’ policies before. They were an abject failure by every metric, only creating chaos, dysfunction, and profound human suffering at our nation’s doorstep. If this bill passes, it will mark a complete abdication of the United States’ legal and moral commitments to refugees and a stunning betrayal of President Biden’s promise to restore our ‘historic role as a safe haven’ for those escaping persecution.”

“We can now read the text of the extreme Republican Trojan Horse border bill, one that when wheeled into Congress invites acceptance by claiming to be a bi-partisan offering of a panacea for real comprehensive immigration reform. In reality, in its true shape and form, it is a bill designed with clear intent to eviscerate our asylum system and replace it with a carceral and deterrence structure of maximal force,” said Thomas Cartwright, leadership team at Witness at the Border. “This bill provides no solutions to our outmoded immigration system. It will instead create confusion and chaos at the border and inflict immeasurable harm on those fleeing to us for protection, and to the moral fabric of this country that used to stand as an example of fairness and compassion. We urge the White House to stand down and Democratic Senators to see this Trojan Horse bill for what it is – a ploy to invert your humanitarian beliefs for the promise of an illusion of a remedy.”

“Closing the border, creating a new ‘metering’ system, and debilitating our asylum laws will do nothing to address the underlying issues that force vulnerable children and families to flee their homes, seeking safety and a better life,” said Marisa Limón Garza, Executive Director of Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center in El Paso, Texas, and Ciudad Juárez, Chihuahua. “A humane immigration system should prioritize human lives and outcomes over performatively turning people away. Every person deserves a fair chance to have their case heard, regardless of their position in line. We urge Congress and the Biden Administration to reject this mistaken approach and use this opportunity to uplift their promise to restore humanity to our asylum system instead.”

“Removing judicial review and the ability to appeal from asylum decisions is a grave violation of due process rights for a proceeding that has the highest possible stakes – life or death,” said Priscilla Orta, Supervising Director of Project Corazon at Lawyers for Good Government. “This is just one of many threats to the fundamental principles of human rights present in the Senate supplemental funding bill, which will certainly disproportionately endanger the lives of Black, Indigenous, LGBTQI+, women, and children asylum seekers. These measures are not about enhancing border security but about closing our doors to those in dire need of sanctuary.”

“The proposed legislation is a step in the wrong direction and instead marks a disturbing escalation beyond even what we saw under the Trump Administration,” said Estuardo Cifuentes, a Guatemalan Asylum Seeker and Client Manager of Lawyers for Good Government’s Project Corazon. “We must remember these policies will impact real people fleeing persecution and danger, people in extremely vulnerable conditions who have stories, dreams, and the fundamental right to seeking safety. As a nation, we have the power and responsibility to offer more than just shelter. Any immigration reform should align with our deepest values ​​and our long-term commitment to justice and humanity”

“The Trump-style deal announced yesterday is a cynical attempt to use Afghan evacuees as a political bargaining chip, trading away a precious lifeline that Afghans left behind have used to seek safety and asylum on our border,” said Arash Azizzada, co-director for Afghans For A Better Tomorrow. “We cannot in good conscience accept a toxic deal that destroys these life-saving protections and pits one group of Afghans against another as well as others seeking asylum.”

“While bipartisanship requires political compromise, it does not require compromising our nation’s core values,” said Krish O’Mara Vignarajah, President and CEO of Global Refuge. “Migration poses a complex challenge, but without robust humanitarian exceptions, summary expulsions risk violating international law enacted precisely to safeguard against the refoulement of vulnerable people back to danger. Similarly, moving the goalposts on initial asylum eligibility would ultimately deny protection to persecuted individuals and families based on increasingly arbitrary factors, and not on the merits of their claim. Building additional legal pathways should be the cornerstone of any effort to alleviate strain on the border, and should have been a more pronounced priority in these negotiations.”

“While we recognize that there are undeniable challenges at our southern border, this so-called Senate deal would do nothing to alleviate that pressure and would undermine asylum protections for people fleeing for their lives,” said HIAS President and CEO Mark Hetfield. “The United States needs to stop trying to patch up our broken immigration and asylum system, and instead enact comprehensive immigration reform. The Senate bill would undermine U.S. asylum law, endangering people attempting to seek protection in this country during an unprecedented global displacement crisis. Instead of making our nation safer and leading by the power of our example, this bill would make it almost impossible for people to access asylum, while at the same time creating uncertainty and chaos.”

“If this bill becomes law, it spells out a scary future—more families torn apart, more innocent children confined, and more individuals forcibly returned to the brutal realities of persecution, torture, and potential death,” said Fatima Saidi, Director of We Are All America. “Our laws should always and consistently prioritize human lives and human dignity. The rights of those seeking asylum should be safeguarded, not treated as pawns in political negotiations, and we shouldn’t give in to the political spectacle of turning people away. Every person deserves a reliable chance to present their case, regardless of where they stand in the queue. For the past four decades, we have witnessed that relying on deterrence and enforcement to bring order to the border is futile, and this doomed package is set to continue that pattern of failure.” 

“This bill reflects a decision to engage in harmful, illegal, and short-sighted political gambling with human lives rather than an earnest attempt to rebuild U.S. immigration policy. People move, especially when faced with danger. And, if the U.S. prioritized safe, orderly, and fair pathways to migration rather than political gamesmanship, we would be a stronger nation,” said Robin Phillips, Executive Director of The Advocates for Human Rights. “Let’s be clear: the provisions as proposed will put the U.S. in violation of international law. Punishing people for seeking safety is precisely what gave rise to the Refugee Convention, and these political maneuvers risk repeating those costly mistakes.”

“NETWORK decries the new harsh policies of expulsion and exclusion of people seeking safety in the U.S. that are included in the Emergency National Security Supplemental Appropriations Act of 2024,” said Mary Novak, Executive Director for NETWORK Lobby for Catholic Social Justice. “The Catholic tradition honors international law that provides human beings the right to seek asylum, and we believe countries have a moral responsibility to care for those seeking help at their borders. This dangerous bill will only lead to more human suffering, especially among Black, Brown, and Indigenous people.”

“As an organization present at the U.S.-Mexico border, we express deep concern over how this bill could further complicate the situation at the border for those seeking safety,” said Joan Rosenhauer, President of Jesuit Refugee Service/USA. “Overall, we support solutions that provide access to asylum and ensure the well-being and safety of those arriving at the U.S.-Mexico border. While this bill misses the mark, we encourage Congress to continue these bipartisan efforts and work towards comprehensive solutions that guarantee access to asylum in a fair, safe, and orderly way.” 

“Attempts to expand non-detained preliminary fear screenings while curtailing due process protections must be rejected—any process in which life or death decisions are being made must, at a bare minimum, provide an opportunity for judicial review,” said Shalyn Fluharty, Executive Director of Americans for Immigrant Justice. “While the proposed legislation does include some welcome provisions, such as appointed legal counsel for unaccompanied children and individuals deemed unable to represent themselves, and numerous provisions in relation to expanding access to legal permanent residence status to certain groups, including our Afghan Allies—these sweeteners cannot cure a sour deal. We must safeguard protections for all people seeking safety and opportunity in the United States, not just a select few.”  

“We are witnessing an unprecedented crisis of global displacement and insecurity that requires a comprehensive approach aimed at addressing the root causes of migration, increasing and streamlining lawful pathways for migration and strengthening our strained U.S. asylum system,” said Cindy Woods, National Policy Counsel at Americans for Immigrant Justice. “The changes to asylum and border processing included in the supplemental funding bill would do nothing more than sow havoc at the Southern Border, return vulnerable individuals back into harm’s way, and fundamentally deny due process to asylum seekers in the United States.” 

“Immigration is not just an issue or campaign tactic—it’s fundamentally about people and what they need and how we as a nation treat them,” said Karen Tumlin, Founder and DIrector of Justice Action Center. “Those of us who have worked with asylum seekers know that our communities are enriched by their presence. The process by which this bill has come about puts politics over people. We’ve seen these tactics used before, and lived experience should teach us that the proposed border ‘deterrence’ measures are not only ineffective, but counterproductive to achieving the reforms and modernized processes we need. They will not stop people fleeing for their lives from seeking safety.”

“What we see cannot be called a compromise. These recycled, cruel, and ineffective deterrence-based policies have no place in any modern-day, good-faith immigration reform effort,” said Casey Carter Swegman, Director of Public Policy at the Tahirih Justice Center. “We already know the impact these harmful policy proposals will have. They will gut the asylum system and effectively slam the door in the face of immigrant survivors fleeing gender-based violence seeking to exercise their right to apply for asylum in the U.S. Not only are these policies destined to fail to address the challenges along our border, the harm they will cause will land disproportionately on already marginalized immigrant survivors of color. This deal is a betrayal of our ideals and we demand that this Administration and the Senate do better. Nothing is worth trading away the lives and safety of immigrant survivors.”

“We are outraged that the Senate is advancing such harmful, anti-immigrant legislation,” said Sirine Shebaya, Executive Director of the National Immigration Project. “Last week, the House of Representatives showed its willingness to scapegoat and demonize immigrant communities through its passage of four anti-immigrant bills, and this week, Senate leaders have decided to sell out immigrant communities in exchange for foreign aid. The proposals in this Senate bill would subject people to expulsion without due process, expand this country’s inhumane detention apparatus, and exacerbate human rights abuses at the border. This bill would lead to tragedy and loss of life and would eviscerate our most dearly-held values. It does not offer any real solutions – it would only exacerbate the same ‘border crisis’ while causing even more human suffering. As a nationwide membership organization, the National Immigration Project is committed to working hand in hand with its partners and members across the country to continue demanding that Congress and the Biden administration reject these harmful anti-immigrant frameworks and instead take bold action to implement policies that create a more just and humane immigration system.”

“Trading away human life, safety, and dignity is not a compromise, it is a moral and humanitarian failure that cuts away at our proclaimed values as a country and society,” said Sue Roche, Executive Director at the Immigrant Legal Advocacy Project (ILAP) in Maine. “ILAP stands with asylum seekers and the right to seek asylum and calls on lawmakers to reject the proposed Emergency National Security Supplemental Appropriations Act of 2024. Language in the bill about asylum flies in the face of international law and would strip away due process for incredibly vulnerable people, permitting rapid expulsions that will inevitably strand people in Mexico and leave them in peril, among other dangerous provisions. We can and must build a just and welcoming asylum system and lawmakers should come to the table with strategies that improve access and preserve and expand human and legal rights – using people fleeing for their lives as political fodder is unacceptable.”

“Compassion and human rights must guide our treatment of those seeking refuge and a better life for their families. The Senate’s proposal is filled with callousness, militarism, and political gamesmanship,” said Matt Nelson, Executive Director of Presente.org. “If passed, this dangerous, white supremacist agenda will weaken our asylum system, ramp up deportations, deny asylum seekers due process, and put people’s lives at risk. We urge our leaders to align with dignity, let our values guide our policy, and enact a transformative immigration program that provides permanent protections for undocumented families, expedites work permits for newly arrived migrants, and increases funding to those welcoming migrants with dignity.” 

“It is deeply disappointing to see the U.S. go down an unconscionable path of obliterating our asylum protections through hasty negotiations that do nothing to address the root causes of displacement,” said Nili Sarit Yossinger, Executive Director of Refugee Congress. “The expanded use of detention, heightened standards for asylum claims, and new expulsion authority will also create confusion in the process of assessing these claims. These proposed compromises will not only further endanger people who are seeking safety, but it will undermine our security and the credibility of our protection laws. At a time when we are facing historic levels of forced displacement, we should be crafting solutions that are people-centered, not fear-centered.”

“As an organization that assists and accompanies people fleeing violence and persecution and desperately seeking protection in the U.S., we are concerned that the restrictive proposals will cause further harm and create chaos at the border. Under the current bill, access to safety will become a game of chance and luck, which is inhumane, unfair and contradictory to the values by which this great nation stands,” said Joanna Williams, Executive Director of the Kino Border Initiative. “The Senators don’t have a practical, on the ground understanding of these issues and do not seem to realize that further tightening access to asylum at the border only benefits organized crime, who exploit the lack of legal pathways for their benefit and who profit from people’s desperation and need. As such, we oppose the current proposal unless it is significantly revised to be realigned with humanity and common sense.”

“We are in a period of historic migration worldwide. It’s not just the United States: many countries throughout the hemisphere are receiving hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of migrants, refugees, and asylum seekers,” said Maureen Meyer, Vice President for Programs at the Washington Office on Latin America. “This is a moment when the United States should be leading its regional neighbors on a humanitarian response, building up its broken asylum system, and investing in processing and due process guarantees. Instead, this bill’s provisions include a historic partial dismantlement of the right to seek asylum at the U.S. border. This is a step in the wrong direction whose impact will reverberate throughout the Americas. It goes against U.S. commitments under the Refugee Convention, it will place many people directly in harm’s way, and—as the Title 42 experience showed us—it won’t reduce or deter migration at the U.S.-Mexico border.”

“This bill is a disgrace, plain and simple,” said Laura St. John, Florence Project Immigrant & Refugee Rights Project Legal Director. “It embraces extreme restrictions on asylum and policies that will cause immense human suffering at the border and for all seeking protection in the United States. Despite President Biden’s campaign promises to restore humanity to our immigration system, instead he is supporting and in fact encouraging policies that will lead to families being separated, will put the lives of people seeking protection in grave danger, and create the very conditions of confusion and instability in which cartels and transnational criminal organizations thrive.”

“The cruelty at the border needs to stop,” said Dylan Corbett, executive director of the Hope Border Institute. “The provisions outlined in the appropriations bill, purporting to automatically shut down the border and expel individuals seeking safety, are a catalyst for increased chaos on both the US and Mexican sides. Any policy that fails to acknowledge the complex realities of migration and prioritizes enforcement over compassion is fundamentally flawed; failing to do so will result in deaths, extortion, and kidnappings across the US-Mexico border. We call on policymakers to reject these harmful provisions and instead work towards comprehensive solutions that honor our nation’s commitment to human dignity and justice.”

“History teaches that it is both immoral and impossible to stop people fleeing harm from seeking refuge in the United States. There is no acceptable ‘price’ for abandoning the commitment to protecting those who come here fleeing persecution; nor any justification for massively expanding resources to imprison more immigrants,” said Monika Y. Langarica, Senior Staff Attorney at the Center for Immigration Law and Policy at UCLA School of Law. “The senate bill represents a drastic shift in immigration policy that will endanger countless lives. Lawmakers must reject the bill’s drastic departure from our humanitarian commitments.”

“The tragedy of this bill is that there actually is bipartisan support to reform and modernize the sorely outdated U.S. immigration system,” said Sunil Varghese, Policy Director at the International Refugee Assistance Project (IRAP). “There is a strong desire in this country to bring people out of the shadows, attract workers and entrepreneurs, reunite families, and welcome people seeking safety. But this product of secret backroom negotiations solely aimed to address a false and xenophobic narrative of fear and invasion at the border falls dramatically short. The inclusion of positive provisions such as a pathway to permanent status for Afghan parolees and expanded access to legal counsel for unaccompanied children do not lessen the cruelty of this bill. The administration and authors of the bill are pitting vulnerable populations against each other in a doomed attempt to win support from hardliners who have no real interest in creating a functional immigration system. The only thing they have accomplished is to move the starting conversation further to the right.”

“This bill is the harshest anti-immigrant and anti-asylum bill in decades, chock-full of ineffective deterrence-only policies,” said Lindsay Toczylowski, Executive Director, Immigrant Defenders Law Center. “As so often happens during election years, immigrants are being treated like punching bags to score cheap political points. Our representatives need to stop playing politics with immigrant lives and focus instead on following domestic and international laws, which obligate us to protect those fleeing persecution and to give asylum seekers an opportunity to be heard by an immigration judge.” 

“Instead of turning our backs on the most vulnerable—including families and children—we should restore humanity to our immigration and asylum system,” said Margaret Cargioli, Directing Attorney for Policy and Advocacy, Immigrant Defenders Law Center. “Our representatives must stand up for immigrants and refugees by soundly rejecting draconian border enforcement policies that have proven, time and again, not to work. Lest we forget, policies like those being proposed now would send people back to danger. We are talking about human beings.”

“The “bipartisan” National Security Supplemental Funding Bill agreement is a recycling of immigration policies that have been tried in the past and failed to address the challenges at our border while falsely labeling them as “solutions” to an outdated immigration system. We urge all senators to see the bill for what it is, a recipe for disaster, and to vote no”, said Sarah Gavigan, Senior Immigration Attorney at the Central American Resource Center of Northern California – CARECEN SF.  “The new senate supplemental funding bill proposes a permanent border expulsion authority which we saw fail with Title 42 and the Remain in Mexico program – turning away people who are fleeing for their lives does nothing to reduce the harm they face. People want real solutions to the humanitarian needs at the border, and want U.S. foreign policy to address the root causes of migration, thus CARECEN SF opposes this outrageous bipartisan border proposal that will hurt asylum seekers and our communities, and we call on Congress to sit down and finally have an honest discussion to find a workable path that deals humanely with all aspects of our outdated immigration system.”

“All families should be together and safe. While this deal includes a small increase to family visas, it doesn’t outline long-term changes that address the family visa backlogs,” said Alaide Vilchis Ibarra, campaign director at Value Our Families. “Legislators must prioritize increasing family-based immigration pathways, as it remains a viable and dignified way to address the flow of immigrants coming to our country. But as a coalition, we can’t value the lives and well-being of some immigrant families over others. Families stuck in the decades-long visa process should be able to reunite with their loved ones, and families fleeing violence and danger should be able to rebuild their lives in peace and safety. We can build an immigration system that is effective and honors our values.”

“There are real challenges at the border, but eviscerating protections for people seeking asylum and forcing people back to danger will only lead to more chaos and suffering,”  said Maribel Hernández Rivera, director of policy and government affairs for border and immigration at the American Civil Liberties Union. “We need our elected leaders to show moral courage and reject this extreme, anti-immigrant bill. Instead, they must show the moral courage to pass humane and sensible solutions that will improve border management and address the immigration case backlog.”

“This legislation imposes a limit on the number of asylum cases that may be processed, resulting in the rejection of individuals seeking refuge, particularly Indigenous peoples groups, who experience many factors of marginalization like forced displacement from their ancestral territories of origin. Additionally, it infringes upon people’s fundamental human right to seek asylum,” said Lola Marina Juan, Interim Executive Director for Comunidad Maya Pixan Ixim. “We advocate for legislation that respects the rights of indigenous peoples and all individuals requesting asylum be upheld, and funding be allocated for language access for indigenous peoples instead of asylum restrictions.”

“Immigrants cannot and should not be used as political pawns,” said Katharina Obser, director of the Migrant Rights and Justice program at the Women’s Refugee Commission. “The Women’s Refugee Commission has long researched and recommended real solutions to improving U.S. border management and the asylum system. An orderly and humane system requires building increased asylum processing capacity at ports of entry, developing more safe legal pathways to migrate, and resourcing local communities at the border and around the country that help people navigate the U.S. immigration process. We urge Congress and the Biden administration to reverse course and invest in smart, pragmatic, and humane solutions.”

“Our country needs an investment in our shared values and in our communities. It is crucial that we face growing displacement with compassion and meaningful solutions. As proposed, this legislation would undermine our beliefs and turn our back on moral and legal obligations to welcome the persecuted,” said Erol Kekic, Senior Vice President at CWS. “The legislation includes vital funding for resettlement, a path to permanency for Afghans fleeing the Taliban, needed services for Ukrainians among us, and reuniting families forced to flee their homes. Although we support those measures, the administration and Congress must work to pass legislation that addresses these needs without causing unconscionable harm to vulnerable other populations.”